Patients seen in emergency departments were twice as likely to receive an antibiotic only when needed, compared to patients seen in outpatient clinics, according to a news study to appearing in the American Journal of Infection Control (AJIC), the journal of the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology (APIC) in May 2019. The researchers say that this finding suggests patients seen in the emergency room are more likely to have legitimate antibiotic needs.
According to the study, outpatient healthcare providers inappropriately prescribed antibiotics to 40 percent of patients in a major Veterans Affairs (VA healthcare system, a higher figure than in previous studies examining outpatient antibiotic use.
In order to understand the most common causes of inappropriate antibiotic use, researchers within the Veterans Affairs Western New York Healthcare System used an electronic antibiotic alert following the patient being given the prescription They ultimately identified four conditions (urinary tract infections (UTIs), bronchitis, sinusitis, skin structure infections) that frequently led to over-prescribing. The VA study also identified the most commonly overused antibiotics, which included azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, amoxicillin/clavulanate, and cephalexin. Together, these four drugs accounted for nearly 80 percent of unnecessary drug use in the outpatient setting.
Taking a Look at Improper Use of Antibiotics
Outpatient antibiotic prescriptions comprise 60 percent of overall antibiotic use, making them a critical target for antimicrobial stewardship initiatives. Improper use of antibiotics has been associated with increased morbidity, costs, and the proliferation of resistant bacteria. According to the CDC, antibiotic resistance occurs when bacteria develop the ability to defeat the drugs designed to kill them. Stewardship programs focus on optimizing antibiotic use.
The study’s findings indicate that patient-provider relationship may also be key to understanding misuse, as healthcare providers may feel a compelled to prescribe to achieve higher patient satisfaction scores.
Patients with a diagnosis of sinusitis did not require an antibiotic in 32 percent of cases, as their symptoms were consistent with the common cold. Furthermore, with a sinusitis diagnosis, the incorrect drug was chosen in 53 percent of cases, say the researchers.
The study’s findings also revealed 50 percent of the 288 prescriptions for azithromycin were deemed unnecessary – it was most commonly misused for bronchitis, sinusitis, upper respiratory tract infections, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and community-acquired pneumonia.
In addition, the findings revealed that prescribing patterns associated with UTIs indicate that the correct drug was chosen in 54.9 percent of cases. Antibiotics were most commonly prescribed for asymptomatic urine bacteria, a condition that does not require antibiotics.
Beginning a Stewardship Program
“Our study targeted the most commonly overused antibiotics and the associated conditions in order to enable an approach focused on these factors in the outpatient setting,” said Alexis White, PharmD, lead study author, in announcing the publication of this study on April 16. “We found that real-time alerts when an antibiotic is prescribed, allowing for immediate intervention, may be an effective way to begin a stewardship program, supplemented by patient education on when an antibiotic is not needed and the harmful effects of misuse,” notes White.
The alert system used in the study enabled the VA researchers to conduct a thorough chart review of all antibiotic prescriptions, evaluating for set criteria and stewardship targets. A drug’s use as first-line therapy, dosing, and duration were all used as benchmarks for appropriate prescription, they say.
Antimicrobial stewardship programs are common in inpatient scenarios, but this research reinforces the point that there continues to be a significant need to build momentum for such initiatives in the setting,” said 2019 APIC President Karen Hoffmann, RN, MS, CIC, FSHEA, FAPIC. “Using a targeted approach, as recommended by the study authors, may be an effective intervention to reduce inappropriate prescribing,” she says.
This research study, detailed in the article “Antibiotic stewardship targets in the outpatient setting,” by Alexis T. White, Collin M. Clark, John A. Sellick, and Kari A. Mergenhagen, will appear in the American Journal of Infection Control, volume 47, issue 5 (May 2019) published by Elsevier. It is openly available at https://www.ajicjournal.org/article/S0196-6553(19)30071-9/fulltext.